Retake - Walking On the Moon

In my first retake post, I asked who performed "Come Together" better - The Beatles or Aerosmith.

In this retake post, I am asking which band does "Walking On the Moon" come more naturally.

If you are over the moon with "Walking On the Moon," who captures the lunar moment better - The Police or Duran Duran?

Consider both videos below and watch as often as you need to help make a decision.  Consider both bands overall and weigh favorite songs from both or either.  Consider vocals - Sting v. Simon Le Bon.  Consider drums - Stewart Copeland v. Roger Taylor.  Consider distinct genres - similar and different.

Just listen.